by Jeff Fisher
In it's simplest configuration, an HDMI Cable carries picture and sound from a source, like a DVD player, to a display, like a flat-screen TV. How many home theater systems are that simple? In our experience, not many. There is nearly always more than one video source. There is often more than one video destination device. (Perhaps one TV in the living room and another in the master bedroom.) And one or more of the destinations may be further away or more difficult to wire than is possible with a pre-terminated HDMI cable. So what to do?
It Doesn't Work!
Most people (myself included) tried to plug together HDMI splitters, switchers and extenders, along with a handful of HDMI cables to achieve the desired "topology" (how things are connected together). This usually didn't work. Some displays had picture but no sound, some had sound but no picture, some had a picture that would flash on and off every few seconds, and with each different source selected, the displays might have a completely different set of problems. Maybe some of the "paths" would work, but rarely all of them, and often the results would change from day to day. Massively frustrating.
Even more frustrating was that often very similar configurations would work perfectly. And then there were the times that even an extremely simple setup with a single HDMI cable wouldn't work! What was going on here? So I did some research: I talked to our vendors, read explanations from source and display manufacturers (that often sounded more like excuses), studied HDMI standards and testing, andmost importantlyread everything I could find about troubleshooting HDMI problems.
Why Doesn't It Work?
Let's look at some of the problems with "daisy-chaining" HDMI splitters, switches and extenders. (If you're impatient and just want to get to the answer, skip to the next section.)
- Some of you may remember that some combinations of early HDMI products wouldn't work together at all. While much blame was initially placed on cables, a couple of manufacturers eventually admitted that they didn't meet the spec and subsequently fixed their problems. Some of that equipment is still around. If you're having trouble with HDMI between a particular source device and a display, and the source device is relatively old (in HDMI terms, pre-v1.3 / pre-2006), the source device may be to blame.
- It turns out that all of these "active" HDMI devices contain chips that run complicated software (technically, "firmware"). This firmware is written to meet a specific version of the HDMI specification, one that may be different than the other equipment in the chain. The firmware probably assumes that it is talking directly to the source device(s) on one end and the display device(s) on the other. Switches, splitters, and extenders are not transparent! Each time you insert another HDMI device in the chain it adds another firmware layer and increases the likelihood of an incompatibility. A device can work perfectly in the simple configurations the manufacturer tests it in, and it can meet spec, but it can still fail when used with other interconnecting devices because of version differences.
- The HDMI specification doesn't adequately address splitters and routers. If it did, many of the existing incompatibilities could be eliminated. When designing switchers, splitters, and extenders, manufacturers make many decisions affecting the compatibility with other interconnecting devices with little guidance. Often manufacturers purchase chips with the firmware already installed. So the chip manufacturer is making these decisions. More than once I've seen a splitter and switch from the same company that was incompatible because the manufacturer used chips from different sources in each.
- The source device puts a voltage on the HDMI cable. The display device and intermediate active devices can pull current from the source. The resulting voltage drop can cause all kinds of problems. Since "self-powered" active devices, such as an extender without a separate power supply, get their power from this line, when the voltage on that line drops too far, they can quit working. Which device draws and/or supplies power? Do they draw or supply the power all the time or just when they are turned on? This problem alone makes it impossible to guarantee that a complex HDMI configuration will work.
- HDMI keeps changing. It's very complex, very high speed, and equipment is sold at commodity prices. (Sometimes I wonder how it works at all.) While it's a good thing that HDMI is keeping up with consumer demand for new features, it makes it difficult for manufacturers of all the "glue" equipment (chips, cables, splitters, switches, extenders, etc.) to keep up. And every time a new version comes out, it at least doubles the number of combinations and permutations of HDMI versions that may be used in a single installation.
- Lastly, the biggie: The HDMI protocol includes a negotiating process between the source device and the sink (usually display) device. The two devices talk together to decide all kinds of things, like the ultimate dimensions of the video stream, and whether copy protection could be violated. The copy protection failure is the primary reason for the "flashing on and off" and "picture for about 10 seconds then nothing" video problem. Imagine that there are multiple displays connected to a single source, and multiple splitters/switches/extenders in-between them. This negotiation process automatically includes all these active devices and can be quite unpredictable. Even when everything works, keep in mind that the negotiation will result in a video feed selected to work on the lowest definition monitor. A higher definition display in this configuration would be presented with a lower resolution image than it is capable of displaying.
To complicate matters further, you can imagine that the equipment power-on sequence can cause different results! As well as the current power on, power off (standby) and unplugged state of each piece.
What Will Work
The objective when designing an HDMI interconnect scheme is to keep the number of devices in the "chain" to a minimum. More multipurpose devices are appearing on the market to make this easier. A "2 input, 4 output" HDMI switch/splitter is more likely to work than a separate switch and splitter because it is designed and tested as a single unit. It counts as only one link in the HDMI chain rather than two.
We carry HDMI combination devices that combine a switch and splitter, and devices that combine a splitter and extenders. Even though these products are sometimes more expensive than the cheapest of the separate versions, at least you can expect that these will work for you!
Register (under "Log In" above) to leave a comment.